{ "schema_version": 2, "engine_version": "0.13.0", "engine_sha": "81b48b7bb1e5a28e9d5dc8bd36c4c0ffe9d59813", "reference": { "tool": "pvlib", "version": "0.15.2", "radiation_db": "PVGIS-ERA5", "meteo_db": "ERA5", "year_min": 2005, "year_max": 2023, "module": "Canadian_Solar_Inc__CS6K_275M", "inverter": "ABB__PVI_10_0_I_OUTD_x_US_480_y_z__480V_", "tilt_deg": 10.0, "modelchain": { "ac_model": "sandia", "aoi_model": "physical", "dc_model": "cec", "faiman_parameters": "{\"u0\": 25.0, \"u1\": 6.84}", "losses_model": "no_loss", "solar_position_method": "nrel_numpy", "spectral_model": "no_loss" } }, "tolerance_source": "tools/oracle/tolerances.toml", "tolerances": { "solar_position": { "zenith_max_abs_diff_deg": 0.01, "azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg": 0.01, "aoi_max_abs_diff_deg": 0.01, "elevation_threshold_deg": 0.0 }, "poa": { "hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2": 2.0, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 1.0, "annual_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.5, "irradiance_threshold_w_m2": 50.0 }, "effective_irradiance": { "annual_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.5 }, "cell_temperature": { "hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c": 0.2, "irradiance_threshold_w_m2": 50.0 }, "dc_power": { "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.5, "annual_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.5, "power_threshold_pnom_pct": 1.0 }, "ac_power": { "annual_max_rel_diff_pct": 1.0, "monthly_max_rel_diff_pct": 1.5 }, "iav": { "interannual_sigma_max_diff_pp": 0.1 } }, "formulation": [ { "stage": "solar_position", "label": "Posisi matahari (zenith, azimuth, sudut datang)", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/solar_position.md" }, { "stage": "ghi", "label": "GHI tahunan (horizontal)", "status": "weather", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/ghi.md" }, { "stage": "adjusted_ghi", "label": "GHI setelah koreksi spektral", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/adjusted_ghi.md" }, { "stage": "poa_irradiance", "label": "Irradiance bidang modul (POA)", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/poa_irradiance.md" }, { "stage": "shaded_irradiance", "label": "Setelah bayangan", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/shaded_irradiance.md" }, { "stage": "effective_irradiance", "label": "Setelah pantulan (IAM)", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/effective_irradiance.md" }, { "stage": "soiled_irradiance", "label": "Setelah soiling", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/soiled_irradiance.md" }, { "stage": "total_irradiance", "label": "Total irradiance kolektor", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/total_irradiance.md" }, { "stage": "nameplate_power", "label": "Nameplate", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/nameplate_power.md" }, { "stage": "module_irradiance_derated_power", "label": "Output pada tingkat irradiance", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/module_irradiance_derated_power.md" }, { "stage": "module_mpp_power", "label": "Output pada suhu sel", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/module_mpp_power.md" }, { "stage": "module_power", "label": "Output setelah mismatch", "status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#54", "doc": "docs/formulation/module_power.md" }, { "stage": "optimizer_output_power", "label": "Output optimizer", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/optimizer_output_power.md" }, { "stage": "optimal_dc_power", "label": "DC optimal (setelah kabel DC)", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/optimal_dc_power.md" }, { "stage": "actual_dc_power", "label": "DC terbatas inverter (clipping)", "status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "doc": "docs/formulation/actual_dc_power.md" }, { "stage": "ac_power", "label": "Output inverter", "status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "doc": "docs/formulation/ac_power.md" }, { "stage": "energy_to_grid_power", "label": "Energi ke grid (kabel AC, trafo)", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/energy_to_grid_power.md" }, { "stage": "lid_derated_power", "label": "Setelah LID", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/lid_derated_power.md" }, { "stage": "availability_derated_power", "label": "Setelah ketidaktersediaan sistem", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/availability_derated_power.md" }, { "stage": "grid_power", "label": "Terkirim setelah batas ekspor (Permen ESDM 2/2024)", "status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "doc": "docs/formulation/grid_power.md" } ], "cases": [ { "id": "bali_equator_dcac110", "site_id": "bali", "site_name": "Bali", "latitude": -8.672, "longitude": 115.212, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/bali_equator_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "dd8f957e13395be15f417996038af3d69cb99e04acd98e60bc474d1e0f256add", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "68377bce732e8611a796a788f5c0fc4b8a50721065febbad58e840db766d67ef", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 2090.8120783000027, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 2090.812235999175, "oracle_ac_kwh": 20196.88045410002, "engine_ac_kwh": 20397.63095459644, "ac_bias_pct": 0.9939678602972856 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_solar_position_bali", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4443, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.866572692871542e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.998314580006991e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999471165945124e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000038165773367067846, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998314580006991e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999471165945124e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998830007707511e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.866572692871542e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.4170812221457224e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.8663811791366085e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.771355663767596e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4443.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_bali", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3990, "annual_bias_pct": 7.542484260354842e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0008655703582824516, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.008054777145900971, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.004250612463324974, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 4.17469268199108e-6, 5.388009634620093e-6, -0.00002374583251717646, -0.00006791332798280946, -0.00009104158862426593, -0.000056829355504382775, 0.000022641566161207104, 0.00006434944592915234, 0.000033714817384188806, 0.000057840402129039975, 0.00010821549565927882, 0.000033351544669961565 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 7.542484260354842e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.008054777145900971, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.004250612463324974, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0001017595287165532 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0008655703582824516 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.00004382676731388261 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.382652225723515e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00016555579466793907 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3990.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_effective_irradiance_bali", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4438, "annual_bias_pct": 7.815420939615132e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0010632326657885815, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.011984190537440043, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0342647288532387, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 3.569972501596841e-6, 5.0356530006367414e-6, -0.00002379945073315598, -0.0000685067428278412, -0.00009357030310605714, -0.000057544059856371355, 0.0000231725020643283, 0.00006520994710070702, 0.000035182663165267305, 0.00005899739784475178, 0.00011064908065567057, 0.00003407410558701169 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 7.815420939615132e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00010204035857923803 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0010632326657885815 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00003620926970015912 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 7.815420920084373e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00022948849529226046 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4438.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_cell_temp_chain_bali", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3990, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.000035857836969123334, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00023874522273104049, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0007308922504922423, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00023874522273104049, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.000035857836969123334 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -1.0556109599775283e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -2.695291439873259e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00009155581430994845 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3990.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4134, "annual_bias_pct": 1.7271423786732458, "hourly_rmse": 102.7485285161786, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 327.9855814796847, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.126302707436498, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.022980164489598453, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.7467134193201495, 1.8758566463137714, 2.0648546180521246, 2.072687740596608, 1.9560099215807765, 1.3071991415539443, 1.3065203254736808, 1.4709952808332256, 1.7297003692997834, 1.9181273817736888, 1.9106256522034566, 1.229479753646301 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.7271423786732458, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.126302707436498, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 30.86202522280797 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 102.7485285161786 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 86.80956557455099 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.718793247724911 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0343780764069526 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.022980164489598453 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4134.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4167, "annual_bias_pct": 0.9939678602971865, "hourly_rmse": 66.15308299220351, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 241.43591822049711, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 12645.628501684221, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.1777111564179386, 1.2349875762870326, 1.344102414313362, 1.2597385652433222, 1.190387675906862, 0.4710755413892809, 0.4894632426761067, 0.6539965463179798, 0.9252860053843477, 1.1363115586970036, 1.2698274487473054, 0.7358681225220283 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.9939678602971865, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.344102414313362, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 17.671078049534522 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 66.15308299220351 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 46.7778931123145 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.9651167715826359 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3648637345504133 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4167.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "bali_equator_dcac130", "site_id": "bali", "site_name": "Bali", "latitude": -8.672, "longitude": 115.212, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 48, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.3221, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/bali_equator_dcac130.csv", "fixture_sha256": "111a2ff18bc403202d52467926f39c01b8fef0714e69d4f39fdd1b451b8e709d", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 13.221119999999999, "weather_sha256": "68377bce732e8611a796a788f5c0fc4b8a50721065febbad58e840db766d67ef", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 2090.8120783000027, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 2090.812235999175, "oracle_ac_kwh": 24048.59449499998, "engine_ac_kwh": 24383.46883576652, "ac_bias_pct": 1.3924902797798318 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4443, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.866572692871542e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.998314580006991e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999471165945124e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000038165773367067846, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998314580006991e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999471165945124e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998830007707511e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.866572692871542e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.4170812221457224e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.8663811791366085e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.771355663767596e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4443.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3990, "annual_bias_pct": 7.542484260354842e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0008655703582824516, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.008054777145900971, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.004250612463324974, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 4.17469268199108e-6, 5.388009634620093e-6, -0.00002374583251717646, -0.00006791332798280946, -0.00009104158862426593, -0.000056829355504382775, 0.000022641566161207104, 0.00006434944592915234, 0.000033714817384188806, 0.000057840402129039975, 0.00010821549565927882, 0.000033351544669961565 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 7.542484260354842e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.008054777145900971, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.004250612463324974, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0001017595287165532 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0008655703582824516 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.00004382676731388261 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.382652225723515e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00016555579466793907 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3990.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4438, "annual_bias_pct": 7.815420939615132e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0010632326657885815, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.011984190537440043, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0342647288532387, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 3.569972501596841e-6, 5.0356530006367414e-6, -0.00002379945073315598, -0.0000685067428278412, -0.00009357030310605714, -0.000057544059856371355, 0.0000231725020643283, 0.00006520994710070702, 0.000035182663165267305, 0.00005899739784475178, 0.00011064908065567057, 0.00003407410558701169 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 7.815420939615132e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00010204035857923803 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0010632326657885815 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00003620926970015912 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 7.815420920084373e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00022948849529226046 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4438.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3990, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.000035857836969123334, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00023874522273104049, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0007308922504922423, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00023874522273104049, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.000035857836969123334 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -1.0556109599775283e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -2.695291439873259e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00009155581430994845 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3990.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4134, "annual_bias_pct": 1.727142356187564, "hourly_rmse": 123.29823322272777, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 393.58259777561943, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.126302707436498, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.022980164489598453, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.7467134136857683, 1.8758566097230496, 2.064854602742484, 2.0726877127400942, 1.9560099185768092, 1.3071990916864273, 1.3065203515192763, 1.470995272853413, 1.7297003522427277, 1.9181273850357574, 1.9106255975864808, 1.2294796527803258 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.727142356187564, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.126302707436498, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 37.03442986027742 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 123.29823322272777 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 104.17147769768533 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.718793231079691 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0343780596290655 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.022980164489598453 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4134.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4178, "annual_bias_pct": 1.3924902797812226, "hourly_rmse": 166.07257819587485, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 576.8959999999988, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 14499.63991285626, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.2151823353470168, 1.3653975457072884, 1.8685423977423021, 2.227504596585841, 1.3483371832915778, 0.3637744363938199, 0.39535692039805587, 1.231892333024258, 1.5136857652823945, 2.4134654373422904, 1.3364728214035821, 1.024905555133206 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3924902797812226, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.4134654373422904, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 31.403008629244667 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 166.07257819587485 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 78.70591708439852 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3673702288380547 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.8852049205895423 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4178.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "bali_reverse_dcac110", "site_id": "bali", "site_name": "Bali", "latitude": -8.672, "longitude": 115.212, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/bali_reverse_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "a679781a5ed2606a67cafdfd8b567ce8ecb892717e939df0c5c4221c08a50309", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "68377bce732e8611a796a788f5c0fc4b8a50721065febbad58e840db766d67ef", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1972.0251715000002, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1972.0253458647107, "oracle_ac_kwh": 19042.620658699998, "engine_ac_kwh": 19232.728356082334, "ac_bias_pct": 0.998327387756275 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4443, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.866572692871542e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.998314580006991e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999471165945124e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000038165773367067846, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998314580006991e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999471165945124e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999670366601094e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.866572692871542e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.4170812221457224e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.8663811791366085e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.771355663767596e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4443.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3987, "annual_bias_pct": 8.841910994820466e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006493336945831247, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.005242994205559626, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005489494465016737, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.000014376258808167466, -0.00003412855763165817, -0.00002820847434977861, 0.00002469570718804178, 0.00006365709581471982, 0.00004776531492296448, -0.000015779457346850284, -0.000038198933543639117, 7.78696876732668e-6, 0.00005396743361340907, 0.000022603389285227308, 0.000014135468464578613 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 8.841910994820466e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.005242994205559626, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005489494465016737, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005759812715572632 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006493336945831247 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00003555650610556577 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 7.208799815894925e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00013164726039357626 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3987.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4438, "annual_bias_pct": 9.13139883289079e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006370541476099439, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.005216023976146289, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.016363154757239273, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.000013920207129839753, -0.000034782746686096776, -0.000029290483772420295, 0.000025573080649835572, 0.00006611375580312112, 0.00005117089351561138, -0.00001620661101842012, -0.000039601528023624, 7.775115597870368e-6, 0.000054946945058107806, 0.00002307790299566504, 0.000013850752316531801 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 9.13139883289079e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005808700294546341 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006370541476099439 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00003979237007653616 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 9.131399036927397e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00014618871956526645 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4438.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3987, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003312130437756365, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00015778339780325723, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0005323305141727719, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00015778339780325723, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003312130437756365 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 7.052212204631253e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.8331805751770214e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008609685875533028 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3987.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4139, "annual_bias_pct": 1.6992435371234966, "hourly_rmse": 95.27889159741, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 318.5661054115153, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.619833916605746, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.023918820971249095, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.7740064436430982, 1.8849814061419459, 1.9879700326519645, 1.9020534310465533, 1.848003009846056, 1.3333443142116481, 1.300962261642027, 1.3668440706469143, 1.6489017177501488, 1.905786596968943, 1.9765893740324232, 1.2213691647198874 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6992435371234966, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.619833916605746, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 28.823581152651013 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 95.27889159741 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 80.45925190086744 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6910479637383964 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0025189374314145 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.023918820971249095 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4139.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4170, "annual_bias_pct": 0.9983273877561089, "hourly_rmse": 63.9465446952127, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 231.7234331950549, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 2887.1156708780472, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.127410471879822, 1.2008335718704548, 1.2634877155083062, 1.117311055811009, 1.2206788253702987, 0.7092420483537131, 0.654884589110656, 0.6106010356326469, 0.8600261281263267, 1.1046425193319676, 1.2894801792221566, 0.6518635082432159 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.9983273877561089, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.2894801792221566, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 16.67479232101903 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 63.9465446952127 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 44.34283826162675 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.971030399991211 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.400317194562238 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4170.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "balikpapan_equator_dcac110", "site_id": "balikpapan", "site_name": "Balikpapan", "latitude": -1.237, "longitude": 116.852, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/balikpapan_equator_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "0d99ba5432935b6e715847eef699356b528c99591cae278671d68e121dc1a830", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "0143a08ed29352d2a3d1edf8fbf845a4145cae73b39fcbf2145d59991f2ebdee", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1891.3909563999953, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1891.3914685163613, "oracle_ac_kwh": 18100.491962699958, "engine_ac_kwh": 18341.82143253925, "ac_bias_pct": 1.3332757492813194 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_solar_position_balikpapan", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4396, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.908325719111663e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.999059797228256e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999843667974346e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000032300446291655364, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999059797228256e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999843667974346e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.996391034239878e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.908325719111663e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": 7.500508815444269e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.54086305467463e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.974703532527946e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4396.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_balikpapan", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3974, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000027076177155926674, "hourly_rmse": 0.0005340299205858868, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.004705011521025426, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0028828589348333204, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -3.375699123580915e-6, -1.3816050483771767e-6, -0.000015190364763519432, -0.000027305421536906764, -0.000028443492156939055, -0.000010044052174271938, 0.000017254409679766603, 0.000040676853026845335, 0.000029658951811726298, 0.00013726403500077044, 0.00016753679239851437, 0.000014603356041235518 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000027076177155926674, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.004705011521025426, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0028828589348333204, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00010294100538826719 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0005340299205858868 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000023499332370103475 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.947535086345996e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00011243433335232266 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3974.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_effective_irradiance_balikpapan", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4378, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000027524167212275963, "hourly_rmse": 0.0010470826266318338, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.016877754193927785, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.07670901513645026, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -2.835570761142148e-6, -1.1755136352964292e-6, -0.000014872113948551759, -0.000027285162435671285, -0.000028453263039981737, -9.839370231467007e-6, 0.00001752900765325683, 0.0000409798591671083, 0.000029460364198610264, 0.0001394264399339177, 0.00016924322894617841, 0.000014441980484406283 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000027524167212275963, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0001026916835973235 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0010470826266318338 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00011720575870335303 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00002752416740631642 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00024589301603007 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4378.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_cell_temp_chain_balikpapan", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3974, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003239167857536427, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00016442476447053878, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00048470055958638766, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00016442476447053878, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003239167857536427 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 1.1248235831881446e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.7248012368794993e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007846642546077619 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3974.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4072, "annual_bias_pct": 2.037672369053772, "hourly_rmse": 104.73221899584014, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 298.4891831084078, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 16.924336326971307, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.041221939747388, 2.133707125540346, 2.2307985285215626, 2.0944413542659923, 2.0575271778488604, 1.9241152158460912, 1.865346932191033, 1.8968402097100818, 2.0160611669658826, 2.1111282412672754, 2.010722323090336, 2.0589191380017224 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.037672369053772, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 16.924336326971307, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 32.03638450362506 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 104.73221899584014 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 93.24736506323589 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0286057811462688 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2784599305638067 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4072.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4082, "annual_bias_pct": 1.333275749281323, "hourly_rmse": 67.14906250610517, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 211.5865037840722, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 22654.900057013787, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.4481092179991015, 1.4740803298350025, 1.5072479446622953, 1.3427890829341644, 1.3093045219328499, 1.2170830864019926, 1.1543404730357603, 1.0961899750670439, 1.1732496625753446, 1.3907341795716728, 1.5054524285297348, 1.4686896736379598 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.333275749281323, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5072479446622953, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 20.241591532964577 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 67.14906250610517 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 57.24236042943987 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.2909224553370604 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.514337144618885 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4082.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "balikpapan_equator_dcac130", "site_id": "balikpapan", "site_name": "Balikpapan", "latitude": -1.237, "longitude": 116.852, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 48, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.3221, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/balikpapan_equator_dcac130.csv", "fixture_sha256": "5bb34dd143712d56efdfd05466abe52e9b7d255fc7212daaeb6a92e8b282e4c8", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 13.221119999999999, "weather_sha256": "0143a08ed29352d2a3d1edf8fbf845a4145cae73b39fcbf2145d59991f2ebdee", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1891.3909563999953, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1891.3914685163613, "oracle_ac_kwh": 21728.151330000048, "engine_ac_kwh": 21997.389991727192, "ac_bias_pct": 1.2391236494906328 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4396, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.908325719111663e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.999059797228256e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999843667974346e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000032300446291655364, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999059797228256e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999843667974346e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.996391034239878e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.908325719111663e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": 7.500508815444269e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.54086305467463e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.974703532527946e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4396.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3974, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000027076177155926674, "hourly_rmse": 0.0005340299205858868, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.004705011521025426, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0028828589348333204, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -3.375699123580915e-6, -1.3816050483771767e-6, -0.000015190364763519432, -0.000027305421536906764, -0.000028443492156939055, -0.000010044052174271938, 0.000017254409679766603, 0.000040676853026845335, 0.000029658951811726298, 0.00013726403500077044, 0.00016753679239851437, 0.000014603356041235518 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000027076177155926674, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.004705011521025426, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0028828589348333204, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00010294100538826719 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0005340299205858868 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000023499332370103475 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.947535086345996e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00011243433335232266 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3974.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4378, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000027524167212275963, "hourly_rmse": 0.0010470826266318338, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.016877754193927785, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.07670901513645026, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -2.835570761142148e-6, -1.1755136352964292e-6, -0.000014872113948551759, -0.000027285162435671285, -0.000028453263039981737, -9.839370231467007e-6, 0.00001752900765325683, 0.0000409798591671083, 0.000029460364198610264, 0.0001394264399339177, 0.00016924322894617841, 0.000014441980484406283 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000027524167212275963, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0001026916835973235 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0010470826266318338 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00011720575870335303 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00002752416740631642 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00024589301603007 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4378.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3974, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003239167857536427, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00016442476447053878, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00048470055958638766, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00016442476447053878, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003239167857536427 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 1.1248235831881446e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.7248012368794993e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007846642546077619 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3974.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4072, "annual_bias_pct": 2.037672370870819, "hourly_rmse": 125.67866327964506, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 358.18707973008895, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 16.924320937117635, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.0412219635010853, 2.1337070616368377, 2.230798514536243, 2.0944414273201963, 2.057527192992042, 1.924115217023848, 1.8653469640539666, 1.8968401626906315, 2.0160611838938047, 2.11112821297795, 2.0107223576580124, 2.058919128941148 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.037672370870819, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 16.924320937117635, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 38.44366141339443 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 125.67866327964506 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 111.89683796782793 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0286057791475844 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.278459939305291 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4072.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4103, "annual_bias_pct": 1.2391236494907243, "hourly_rmse": 100.45260978707203, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 576.8959999999988, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 65758.56266366123, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.1780366552971078, 1.424345429214584, 1.4987405975158705, 1.161738671108536, 1.1400635873981744, 0.9647167032959502, 0.9337903083889524, 1.1495023713379295, 1.3600113388962327, 1.5764777518661497, 1.1954202454923948, 1.1715553609805458 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.2391236494907243, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5764777518661497, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 23.02774577621345 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 100.45260978707203 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 63.830936434503535 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.2053410721102864 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.8968804648708957 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4103.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "balikpapan_reverse_dcac110", "site_id": "balikpapan", "site_name": "Balikpapan", "latitude": -1.237, "longitude": 116.852, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/balikpapan_reverse_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "a590c8184f4ccd6284668d191b9f5242b92fca7a2cd68fcba859cee983127163", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "0143a08ed29352d2a3d1edf8fbf845a4145cae73b39fcbf2145d59991f2ebdee", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1870.4996863999977, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1870.4997476147175, "oracle_ac_kwh": 17883.336502099977, "engine_ac_kwh": 18126.832028456745, "ac_bias_pct": 1.361577725320861 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4396, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.908325719111663e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.999059797228256e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999843667974346e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000032300446291655364, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999059797228256e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999843667974346e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999865765853428e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.908325719111663e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": 7.500508815444269e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.54086305467463e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.974703532527946e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4396.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3978, "annual_bias_pct": 3.272639944506692e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.000498430717033465, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.005805402956781336, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.002968372262131944, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -3.3238178941646185e-6, -0.0000277299326026887, -0.00003217254298732966, -0.000010021132307543472, 1.6275488410843718e-6, -3.0088390320268376e-7, -9.510740044594028e-6, -0.000010605483631690428, 0.000015237955628256486, 0.00008721936877428276, 9.774691803804626e-6, -3.338905940763728e-7 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 3.272639944506692e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.005805402956781336, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.002968372262131944, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0000544287883604431 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000498430717033465 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000017229522797401267 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -3.6725014481790803e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00010624133655044877 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3978.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4378, "annual_bias_pct": 3.2827312544560904e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006206098898047633, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.011659938814780446, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.04115901180548949, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -3.5989017684892433e-6, -0.00002773336303219816, -0.00003288288626060389, -9.736479863890326e-6, 1.0040050510344745e-6, -2.7777438413724877e-7, -9.799825790436571e-6, -0.00001069902332009405, 0.000015377419096560223, 0.00008845342707446305, 0.000010024904759273595, -8.970759099942427e-7 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 3.2827312544560904e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005447223669946068 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006206098898047633 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00001381413832346917 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 3.2827313331207767e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00014747901629488672 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4378.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3978, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003195262873993817, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0001895668409659379, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0005371611084171034, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0001895668409659379, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003195262873993817 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -5.318179128168566e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.29233100221605e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007764569738579295 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3978.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4078, "annual_bias_pct": 2.0541569611626618, "hourly_rmse": 105.053508348192, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 317.955469686407, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.959364756909082, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.1043830485581903, 2.189550445767795, 2.2354708694374725, 2.0563304961429285, 2.0213476025515162, 1.9407133002915085, 1.886140860895114, 1.8507849636989002, 1.9859012521560173, 2.168093613222962, 2.037389379427351, 2.08025936327823 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0541569611626618, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.959364756909082, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 32.079982268765114 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 105.053508348192 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 92.76685471232432 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0454259976078117 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3163356975037543 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4078.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4102, "annual_bias_pct": 1.361577725320964, "hourly_rmse": 68.6831152592469, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 231.14202289895184, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 3198029.768728471, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.4182828980955564, 1.4831247372699576, 1.511087228603851, 1.3542271731685767, 1.3934001500317912, 1.4056658036952827, 1.3106774928216574, 1.1082739614295323, 1.152106758745996, 1.4175332815149015, 1.4291653666015887, 1.362148414087446 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.361577725320964, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.511087228603851, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 20.525682569576002 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 68.6831152592469 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 57.91708376517562 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3284762470182938 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.575422677755615 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4102.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "cikarang_equator_dcac110", "site_id": "cikarang", "site_name": "Cikarang", "latitude": -6.3106, "longitude": 107.1353, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/cikarang_equator_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "643a36cc366e034e7ca0c81eafa2e62e143912d303365965f485bb0909ef38d6", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "e233b66b92c558082b810e16762588a61a6a49301eb4591eb42cd685d19665f3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1950.6083177000025, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1950.6080619800075, "oracle_ac_kwh": 18435.19099410004, "engine_ac_kwh": 18743.79295472506, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6739829857134843 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_solar_position_cikarang", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4367, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.907169575217903e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997610432155852e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.998187250748742e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000042608984146910087, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997610432155852e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998187250748742e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999744476208434e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.907169575217903e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.076513222930552e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.362506491906948e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.963730059572102e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4367.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_cikarang", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3815, "annual_bias_pct": -0.000013109756213264396, "hourly_rmse": 0.00043597976968199855, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0051565267517190705, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005321992830822162, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.000038331238454754365, -0.00004460883619021539, -0.00006266531971322868, -0.000058865266456006795, -0.000011042274182463057, -9.784021764213763e-7, 2.659914728939598e-7, 0.000013810742834992614, 0.000040064424347267396, 0.00002071742244147392, -0.00003413230902475338, -0.000014481747773257656 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013109756213264396, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0051565267517190705, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005321992830822162, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000055477486674167516 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00043597976968199855 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 4.571910725286436e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 9.00622094332386e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008588378838761175 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3815.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_effective_irradiance_cikarang", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4347, "annual_bias_pct": -0.000013287789591014964, "hourly_rmse": 0.0007515897301663786, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.009847723901106775, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.03839074004478048, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.00003967577480254845, -0.00004483262014586125, -0.00006327335405976504, -0.000059377523993026206, -0.000011562749251372613, -8.656720909607419e-7, 4.01175471326961e-8, 0.000013917706144033354, 0.00004081258040917631, 0.00002176085250035985, -0.00003467649120967421, -0.000014561180939791558 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013287789591014964, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005550897725258587 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0007515897301663786 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.00005876260951423802 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013287789567261102 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00016995443629755035 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4347.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_cell_temp_chain_cikarang", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3815, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003173027945035524, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0001749027964308425, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0006699511101737574, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0001749027964308425, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003173027945035524 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -9.456251050816962e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -2.2085313142041887e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007410686898853534 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3815.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4249, "annual_bias_pct": 2.3125708769647733, "hourly_rmse": 125.10435596589812, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 416.5231902308042, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.626366391707318, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.0414448206411913, 1.9907373165555124, 2.2145542105921425, 2.2099702412512214, 2.2675177810365934, 2.1926863313672267, 2.2810813864481077, 2.5513349289561846, 2.8719046891088866, 2.284907592509778, 2.376104229391004, 2.187985026430003 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3125708769647733, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.626366391707318, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 37.626785432771435 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 125.10435596589812 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 103.74474189157083 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.310185399926809 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.7858207688417447 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4249.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4268, "annual_bias_pct": 1.673982985713806, "hourly_rmse": 86.38454423664615, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 329.86982662157243, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 2030.7932044050247, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.5654397824592845, 1.5769951696391407, 1.5541399617440246, 1.5961497824724864, 1.644997115123624, 1.4678944028445304, 1.4890321413842749, 1.7770650365059844, 2.1638273933035785, 1.709998916185212, 1.7793722985593345, 1.6292381111593166 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.673982985713806, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.1638273933035785, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 26.29123068014436 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 86.38454423664615 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 72.14989549120018 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6703692088408169 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.999920884573424 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4268.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "cikarang_equator_dcac130", "site_id": "cikarang", "site_name": "Cikarang", "latitude": -6.3106, "longitude": 107.1353, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 48, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.3221, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/cikarang_equator_dcac130.csv", "fixture_sha256": "7cef47673e11903ed1a1d7caa2824dfe1939c158583c1fc43e658c1685b045bc", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 13.221119999999999, "weather_sha256": "e233b66b92c558082b810e16762588a61a6a49301eb4591eb42cd685d19665f3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1950.6083177000025, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1950.6080619800075, "oracle_ac_kwh": 22092.138274800043, "engine_ac_kwh": 22453.681332821085, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6365236063792186 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4367, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.907169575217903e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997610432155852e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.998187250748742e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000042608984146910087, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997610432155852e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998187250748742e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999744476208434e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.907169575217903e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.076513222930552e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.362506491906948e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.963730059572102e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4367.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3815, "annual_bias_pct": -0.000013109756213264396, "hourly_rmse": 0.00043597976968199855, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0051565267517190705, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005321992830822162, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.000038331238454754365, -0.00004460883619021539, -0.00006266531971322868, -0.000058865266456006795, -0.000011042274182463057, -9.784021764213763e-7, 2.659914728939598e-7, 0.000013810742834992614, 0.000040064424347267396, 0.00002071742244147392, -0.00003413230902475338, -0.000014481747773257656 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013109756213264396, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0051565267517190705, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005321992830822162, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000055477486674167516 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00043597976968199855 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 4.571910725286436e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 9.00622094332386e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008588378838761175 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3815.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4347, "annual_bias_pct": -0.000013287789591014964, "hourly_rmse": 0.0007515897301663786, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.009847723901106775, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.03839074004478048, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.00003967577480254845, -0.00004483262014586125, -0.00006327335405976504, -0.000059377523993026206, -0.000011562749251372613, -8.656720909607419e-7, 4.01175471326961e-8, 0.000013917706144033354, 0.00004081258040917631, 0.00002176085250035985, -0.00003467649120967421, -0.000014561180939791558 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013287789591014964, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005550897725258587 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0007515897301663786 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.00005876260951423802 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013287789567261102 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00016995443629755035 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4347.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3815, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003173027945035524, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0001749027964308425, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0006699511101737574, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0001749027964308425, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003173027945035524 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -9.456251050816962e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -2.2085313142041887e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007410686898853534 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3815.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4249, "annual_bias_pct": 2.312570887865649, "hourly_rmse": 150.12522745217632, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 499.8278082769648, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.626330886416298, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.0414448366545397, 1.9907374165766423, 2.2145542401458234, 2.2099701876480387, 2.267517748295545, 2.1926863809183255, 2.281081474095277, 2.55133501239031, 2.8719047214021387, 2.2849074985223123, 2.3761041935014338, 2.1879849691825717 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.312570887865649, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.626330886416298, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 45.152142769369384 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 150.12522745217632 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 124.49369080177506 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3101854100249173 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.7858207745556283 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4249.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4269, "annual_bias_pct": 1.6365236063793758, "hourly_rmse": 130.10061211017356, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 576.8959999999988, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 757.8321790834855, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.2730710035232609, 1.3017960332199054, 1.5684144841420364, 1.4735946278857317, 1.4435349695516846, 1.366044236323851, 1.585011039922177, 1.9046008468655211, 2.6880653705481405, 1.62841629122464, 1.6283612834522485, 1.3937315958175285 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6365236063793758, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.6880653705481405, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 31.855799572187596 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 130.10061211017356 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 84.52494359185421 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6333275652417198 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.5140142895622803 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4269.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "cikarang_reverse_dcac110", "site_id": "cikarang", "site_name": "Cikarang", "latitude": -6.3106, "longitude": 107.1353, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/cikarang_reverse_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "0e3f97d4eb10737546b1cda0df6c7c46dc5cbac529325ff4e38ccc2c669bbdc6", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "e233b66b92c558082b810e16762588a61a6a49301eb4591eb42cd685d19665f3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1863.4455491000028, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1863.445368756023, "oracle_ac_kwh": 17608.170525499943, "engine_ac_kwh": 17896.00727629887, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6346772106851537 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4367, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.907169575217903e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997610432155852e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.998187250748742e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000042608984146910087, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997610432155852e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998187250748742e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998183555926516e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.907169575217903e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.076513222930552e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.362506491906948e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.963730059572102e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4367.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3822, "annual_bias_pct": -9.677984946965134e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006456290450481936, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.008524135647206776, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005200563605614553, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -1.464262047435987e-6, -0.000013026939416107868, -0.00007332863853156546, -0.00016145229452508574, -0.00013108184803616835, -9.340394070264666e-6, -2.933930681711994e-7, 0.000034823115626069356, 0.00005948877252697883, 0.000025261561616710925, 0.00006885926302447201, 0.00003224525810482696 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -9.677984946965134e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.008524135647206776, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005200563605614553, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00010745575082837 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006456290450481936 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00007062144786547629 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000014580666257354326 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0001332980548605268 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3822.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4347, "annual_bias_pct": -0.000010007847950901655, "hourly_rmse": 0.0012339801047968194, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.012879384432498142, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.047167211480704255, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -1.9942915184782632e-6, -0.000013997477447238788, -0.00007412219520528979, -0.00016521679768588958, -0.0001347174398585026, -9.314566271699746e-6, 4.2496978241097205e-7, 0.00003646940049403298, 0.000060054229493002514, 0.00002577067718485182, 0.00006964724106045948, 0.000032252753605575007 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000010007847950901655, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00010761494700553951 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0012339801047968194 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000042112240179582975 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000010007847966988631 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00029325168241898933 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4347.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3822, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003513870088812122, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0002958570290658713, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0010810563994602018, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0002958570290658713, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003513870088812122 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 2.298383061327558e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 5.457936608511134e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008344335858532806 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3822.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4238, "annual_bias_pct": 2.251089495595133, "hourly_rmse": 114.80173249115798, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 389.3715085742733, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.922757681299167, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.0660552879788363, 1.9757585958536197, 2.1733774176850305, 2.1079577800984897, 2.1463413061651635, 2.0781160466699276, 2.121276346867758, 2.372701506149074, 2.7477537120777114, 2.280075508001371, 2.442005902995299, 2.268920935560348 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.251089495595133, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.922757681299167, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 34.87339382496911 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 114.80173249115798 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 96.67182101151626 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.247619825909364 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.6691402654464462 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4238.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4267, "annual_bias_pct": 1.6346772106848668, "hourly_rmse": 79.60058724236131, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 302.5937042313017, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 5770.442583533123, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.477989588490331, 1.5049413823954594, 1.516267733124514, 1.5715574139000075, 1.672967914936661, 1.5252258588986563, 1.4576399959475153, 1.6641373049796004, 2.050175105538657, 1.6748294035463862, 1.7645329844131585, 1.5942581807225271 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6346772106848668, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.050175105538657, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 24.457640169420124 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 79.60058724236131 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 67.28292453123952 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6304717094773113 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.9289664719640827 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4267.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "cikarang_temperature_faiman", "site_id": "cikarang", "site_name": "Cikarang", "latitude": -6.3106, "longitude": 107.1353, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "faiman", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/cikarang_temperature_faiman.csv", "fixture_sha256": "93530ccc09542d01d3aa2e063deb9f606dbaabc5ce8be4fae63503d1c9d4c23a", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "e233b66b92c558082b810e16762588a61a6a49301eb4591eb42cd685d19665f3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "faiman", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1950.6083177000025, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1950.6080619800075, "oracle_ac_kwh": 18401.21296879999, "engine_ac_kwh": 18717.486254876552, "ac_bias_pct": 1.718763250079303 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4367, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.907169575217903e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997610432155852e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.998187250748742e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000042608984146910087, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997610432155852e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998187250748742e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999744476208434e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.907169575217903e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.076513222930552e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.362506491906948e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.963730059572102e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4367.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3815, "annual_bias_pct": -0.000013109756213264396, "hourly_rmse": 0.00043597976968199855, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0051565267517190705, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005321992830822162, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.000038331238454754365, -0.00004460883619021539, -0.00006266531971322868, -0.000058865266456006795, -0.000011042274182463057, -9.784021764213763e-7, 2.659914728939598e-7, 0.000013810742834992614, 0.000040064424347267396, 0.00002071742244147392, -0.00003413230902475338, -0.000014481747773257656 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013109756213264396, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0051565267517190705, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005321992830822162, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000055477486674167516 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00043597976968199855 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 4.571910725286436e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 9.00622094332386e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008588378838761175 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3815.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4347, "annual_bias_pct": -0.000013287789591014964, "hourly_rmse": 0.0007515897301663786, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.009847723901106775, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.03839074004478048, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.00003967577480254845, -0.00004483262014586125, -0.00006327335405976504, -0.000059377523993026206, -0.000011562749251372613, -8.656720909607419e-7, 4.01175471326961e-8, 0.000013917706144033354, 0.00004081258040917631, 0.00002176085250035985, -0.00003467649120967421, -0.000014561180939791558 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013287789591014964, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005550897725258587 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0007515897301663786 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.00005876260951423802 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -0.000013287789567261102 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00016995443629755035 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4347.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3815, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003126095928371048, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0001622132584202518, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0006329507783263364, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0001622132584202518, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003126095928371048 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -5.933857918467496e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.3770299156949284e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007254517502520181 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3815.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4249, "annual_bias_pct": 2.356131376761173, "hourly_rmse": 128.72869865498262, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 461.48743145337176, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.64889885115247, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.958826610298033, 1.890045623524245, 2.1972198054946674, 2.234945362510473, 2.3499524513197922, 2.2303797556523652, 2.3602822756045216, 2.643402716540638, 2.9438662822468196, 2.434309353964722, 2.4645400135634583, 2.218113354091731 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.356131376761173, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.64889885115247, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 38.38314778314495 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 128.72869865498262 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 105.50765037050199 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3537460171172393 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.8717790670520174 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4249.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4268, "annual_bias_pct": 1.718763250079342, "hourly_rmse": 90.18344335405921, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 374.4975781952362, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 2041.875655937207, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.4774013505490644, 1.4691181144493985, 1.5362935047525446, 1.6220004922635982, 1.7305386400215923, 1.507269232545737, 1.5698969083736352, 1.8713571274449863, 2.237512834050597, 1.8646061987867106, 1.8717995580497402, 1.6608609287541511 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.718763250079342, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.237512834050597, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 27.060683565691335 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 90.18344335405921 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 73.94730281900624 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.7151428493689158 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.091725892677528 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4268.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "cikarang_transposition_haydavies", "site_id": "cikarang", "site_name": "Cikarang", "latitude": -6.3106, "longitude": 107.1353, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "haydavies", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/cikarang_transposition_haydavies.csv", "fixture_sha256": "616d01cab859d54167a0943ef6572015b82eb6dbac7a3ccfacf014d1c57b8f4e", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "e233b66b92c558082b810e16762588a61a6a49301eb4591eb42cd685d19665f3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "haydavies", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1938.8809661000012, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1938.8812152446135, "oracle_ac_kwh": 18331.4787522, "engine_ac_kwh": 18637.360622129352, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6686153586635337 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4367, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.907169575217903e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997610432155852e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.998187250748742e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000042608984146910087, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997610432155852e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998187250748742e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999744476208434e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.907169575217903e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.076513222930552e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.362506491906948e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.963730059572102e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4367.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_cikarang_haydavies", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3805, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000012849917901200047, "hourly_rmse": 0.000679547119775308, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.008949852673822534, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.009268150940201614, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.000013711653904015057, 3.161003334988134e-7, -3.834520919822842e-7, -2.6147401646642296e-7, 1.6476533468110915e-7, 1.7798688929831848e-7, -2.6763649965124963e-7, 3.5623388605029154e-7, -0.000021690594146747064, 0.000043288827162673665, 0.00008957462466123399, 0.00006902405867472341 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000012849917901200047, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.008949852673822534, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.009268150940201614, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0000556150069625617 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000679547119775308 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00006852653719826016 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000013551714552122165 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00013438631176223445 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3805.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4347, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000012860750298115125, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006504161105605906, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.008896917949755334, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.09261509091418155, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.000013752282056425633, 3.0136585688627536e-7, 1.9740978186933816e-8, -5.732334984072013e-7, -7.692610425191917e-7, -5.814547437404402e-7, 5.942716286823648e-8, 2.127412089979168e-7, -0.00002237514592500648, 0.000043941032457159205, 0.00009066477920910208, 0.00007032495261139229 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000012860750298115125, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005547395242406973 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006504161105605906 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000056527154614116265 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000012860750089909461 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0001479791280752307 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4347.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3805, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.000035158434484782446, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0002618923176882504, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0010273348828994148, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0002618923176882504, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.000035158434484782446 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 2.2025851706598498e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 5.150304520480071e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008221096122504565 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3805.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4248, "annual_bias_pct": 2.3048757746846347, "hourly_rmse": 123.82803778873014, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 414.9145554440456, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.34003032424235, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.03636038097343, 1.9908621362818373, 2.2094421338738064, 2.202631871637235, 2.2563284403653605, 2.1850752256907704, 2.2698776520197477, 2.5387375324165804, 2.8615902299235243, 2.278105659503694, 2.373233684408641, 2.181691824862147 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3048757746846347, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.34003032424235, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 37.27952478118271 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 123.82803778873014 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 102.8423817177292 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3024567701611987 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.7722880312610267 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4248.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4266, "annual_bias_pct": 1.6686153586637338, "hourly_rmse": 85.54331289665464, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 328.24686522628144, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 1927.8647878530094, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.5572129473419136, 1.5738095444534659, 1.5497153610892478, 1.5914135605372415, 1.638442294041282, 1.4654652780239492, 1.480186881252408, 1.765702206482338, 2.1533978391536586, 1.7057545438884207, 1.7810226987533377, 1.6304306723116926 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6686153586637338, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.1533978391536586, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 26.051247277412003 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 85.54331289665464 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 71.51637070303316 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6642892891689118 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.9907165032899101 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4266.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "cikarang_transposition_isotropic", "site_id": "cikarang", "site_name": "Cikarang", "latitude": -6.3106, "longitude": 107.1353, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "isotropic", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/cikarang_transposition_isotropic.csv", "fixture_sha256": "d31fdf7847e045b48a0d31382da73ec979a77d88be8ecc41bb8130bf6672972a", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "e233b66b92c558082b810e16762588a61a6a49301eb4591eb42cd685d19665f3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "isotropic", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1935.9730565999964, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1935.9730548934285, "oracle_ac_kwh": 18308.295825299992, "engine_ac_kwh": 18612.97886370678, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6641802236216308 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4367, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.907169575217903e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997610432155852e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.998187250748742e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000042608984146910087, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997610432155852e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998187250748742e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999744476208434e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.907169575217903e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.076513222930552e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.362506491906948e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.963730059572102e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4367.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_cikarang_isotropic", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3815, "annual_bias_pct": -8.815040337272446e-8, "hourly_rmse": 0.000028927601239598272, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00004992231936284952, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00008727258637948453, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -2.562942227688783e-7, -2.0868875316847477e-7, -2.829185660561663e-7, -6.652060704672678e-7, 3.462731924615041e-7, -1.7455336209971301e-7, -5.85623918559828e-8, 2.847383306766015e-7, -3.6240673927900816e-7, -1.7416442433374705e-7, 9.828032402555309e-8, 3.365212834769954e-7 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -8.815040337272446e-8, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00004992231936284952, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008727258637948453, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 5.098445263117898e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000028927601239598272 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -5.063450622223527e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.0053626619879685e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.74365829885348e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3815.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4347, "annual_bias_pct": 3.792729368916306e-9, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002905552112889387, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00004999607165245834, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.03047357943441472, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 6.917239786005862e-7, 3.0653043598027475e-7, 5.56908635378093e-7, -3.474907000696109e-7, 1.2488915109021364e-8, -6.268487250902944e-7, 5.604547313479403e-7, -4.993932955019113e-7, -3.335814281788127e-7, 7.381195052465298e-8, 3.718797528328608e-8, -1.2134104738338624e-7 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 3.792729368916306e-9, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 6.711498954627254e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00002905552112889387 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 1.6645466167364222e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 3.7928582798898546e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 6.620630073209314e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4347.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_cell_temp_cikarang_isotropic_chain", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3815, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002879025375927609, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0000499983063591003, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00019675492333418024, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0000499983063591003, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00002879025375927609 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 1.2123786888401138e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.8401860835164817e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00006744565771461499 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3815.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4250, "annual_bias_pct": 2.3013686461847715, "hourly_rmse": 123.20478007877105, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 414.08238895153045, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.296112302068, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.0411843521270003, 1.98894308771487, 2.208113619271112, 2.1977502791688233, 2.2490159526122357, 2.177677579455831, 2.2613485535124553, 2.529819273257227, 2.85767807270453, 2.2780044941202697, 2.3751760735998677, 2.1862037934404905 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3013686461847715, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.296112302068, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 37.14415430521489 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 123.20478007877105 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 102.51153656845403 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2990473356765184 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.763138968203466 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4250.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4268, "annual_bias_pct": 1.664180223621602, "hourly_rmse": 85.05621512448153, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 327.4073293934707, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 1906.987785616143, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.5481253381171705, 1.566882846845148, 1.5482467808564973, 1.590030019376467, 1.637817570153403, 1.4654276669460498, 1.4775088378003114, 1.759825077812309, 2.151127481852065, 1.7015045377245754, 1.7720956629737605, 1.6161598703951743 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.664180223621602, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.151127481852065, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 25.941588391619252 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 85.05621512448153 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 71.2295944093121 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.660492663215762 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.9828165855264077 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4268.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "makassar_equator_dcac110", "site_id": "makassar", "site_name": "Makassar", "latitude": -5.092, "longitude": 119.495, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/makassar_equator_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "83899f15618478723a9107964086d7dd57c684d952d15f7c9eebe6369006b30b", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "5797023f63b1dae91cf7d0dd3515185264c7e0fb6411402c94b1e592051a0af9", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1890.9277849999976, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1890.9279791129904, "oracle_ac_kwh": 18029.168781700006, "engine_ac_kwh": 18279.909500106078, "ac_bias_pct": 1.3907502971550154 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_solar_position_makassar", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4304, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.9014025990833496e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997419580377027e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.9954400083152e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000018324812670833534, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997419580377027e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.9954400083152e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998895661856295e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.9014025990833496e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.183349808239194e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.7060208605885e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 6.038144719056459e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4304.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_makassar", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3922, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000010265489480100685, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006540164843049784, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.006836905352969325, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0064892441002959685, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -5.595432877604643e-6, -9.645656555335953e-6, -0.000020975862257458554, -0.000034674076517035126, -0.000057592913248451424, -0.00003076158472163189, 0.00001834829599270008, 0.000044899591697148544, 0.00007654823893231519, 0.000057986100798805565, 6.212728223703872e-6, 0.00002851931745763948 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000010265489480100685, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.006836905352969325, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0064892441002959685, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000070044444667771 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006540164843049784 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0000222094967942191 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.6251057282430455e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00013619828562309806 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3922.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_effective_irradiance_makassar", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4253, "annual_bias_pct": 0.00001064161396582944, "hourly_rmse": 0.0007172928144307263, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0077096443953976745, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0249757662192775, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -6.082678710322845e-6, -8.816698780931041e-6, -0.000021865294101557586, -0.00003404449046623336, -0.00005760726666592328, -0.00003148653621395316, 0.000019295890236298023, 0.00004532392138676305, 0.00007804780961196253, 0.00005937669221961127, 6.027803974836908e-6, 0.000029791710977853526 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00001064161396582944, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0000699316229167451 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0007172928144307263 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00004650472450685105 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000010641614065982958 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0001641371577709273 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4253.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_cell_temp_chain_makassar", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3922, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.000034624962722742915, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00019362583289961321, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0007417278608818075, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00019362583289961321, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.000034624962722742915 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 1.0743742511066437e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.639567315521805e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008506804757278301 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3922.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4131, "annual_bias_pct": 2.0675921175394576, "hourly_rmse": 109.62336205712928, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 358.9226521347755, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.23400098065852, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.01961263051189, 1.9308547014362183, 1.900080241669341, 1.9910051520739116, 2.0624366151415523, 2.0320130254225477, 2.0931133984736863, 2.2812864228981264, 2.2829588502402545, 2.0783004785715495, 2.033009543157682, 1.9121660253354025 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0675921175394576, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.23400098065852, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 32.951800126340615 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 109.62336205712928 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 93.23026999884748 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.064655323027755 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.427692829831435 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4131.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4133, "annual_bias_pct": 1.3907502971547148, "hourly_rmse": 73.47380702673384, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 272.0926860493837, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 305.6610789693935, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.842274841781437, 1.422913930555561, 1.1919090345068941, 1.3358167382902357, 1.3210495069096393, 1.3340187816870928, 1.233816865479046, 1.4256697314673719, 1.5103776271023854, 1.3512436069295113, 1.319638019999863, 1.5671872255330357 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3907502971547148, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.842274841781437, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 21.17782426635494 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 73.47380702673384 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 60.08242771175196 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3773273562379742 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6843108416052979 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4133.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "makassar_equator_dcac130", "site_id": "makassar", "site_name": "Makassar", "latitude": -5.092, "longitude": 119.495, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 48, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.3221, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/makassar_equator_dcac130.csv", "fixture_sha256": "a1e01d7e5a6c97475d3f5c6d5ce1aa57419923ef03777c5c79830e9ceeab0ebf", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 13.221119999999999, "weather_sha256": "5797023f63b1dae91cf7d0dd3515185264c7e0fb6411402c94b1e592051a0af9", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1890.9277849999976, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1890.9279791129904, "oracle_ac_kwh": 21593.902874400083, "engine_ac_kwh": 21895.164298022664, "ac_bias_pct": 1.3951226203750877 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4304, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.9014025990833496e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997419580377027e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.9954400083152e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000018324812670833534, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997419580377027e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.9954400083152e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998895661856295e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.9014025990833496e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.183349808239194e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.7060208605885e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 6.038144719056459e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4304.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3922, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000010265489480100685, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006540164843049784, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.006836905352969325, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0064892441002959685, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -5.595432877604643e-6, -9.645656555335953e-6, -0.000020975862257458554, -0.000034674076517035126, -0.000057592913248451424, -0.00003076158472163189, 0.00001834829599270008, 0.000044899591697148544, 0.00007654823893231519, 0.000057986100798805565, 6.212728223703872e-6, 0.00002851931745763948 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000010265489480100685, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.006836905352969325, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0064892441002959685, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000070044444667771 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006540164843049784 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0000222094967942191 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.6251057282430455e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00013619828562309806 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3922.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4253, "annual_bias_pct": 0.00001064161396582944, "hourly_rmse": 0.0007172928144307263, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0077096443953976745, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0249757662192775, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -6.082678710322845e-6, -8.816698780931041e-6, -0.000021865294101557586, -0.00003404449046623336, -0.00005760726666592328, -0.00003148653621395316, 0.000019295890236298023, 0.00004532392138676305, 0.00007804780961196253, 0.00005937669221961127, 6.027803974836908e-6, 0.000029791710977853526 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00001064161396582944, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0000699316229167451 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0007172928144307263 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00004650472450685105 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000010641614065982958 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0001641371577709273 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4253.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3922, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.000034624962722742915, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00019362583289961321, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0007417278608818075, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00019362583289961321, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.000034624962722742915 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 1.0743742511066437e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.639567315521805e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008506804757278301 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3922.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4131, "annual_bias_pct": 2.0675921200924936, "hourly_rmse": 131.54803455592332, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 430.7071825617313, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.234036282056472, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.01961265366685, 1.9308546819211712, 1.9000803944255813, 1.9910052136058083, 2.062436647980986, 2.0320129222200483, 2.0931133456767874, 2.2812864679537443, 2.282958833448891, 2.0783004493120107, 2.0330095237579204, 1.912165984286206 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0675921200924936, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.234036282056472, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 39.54216018119198 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 131.54803455592332 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 111.87632410028658 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0646553249427817 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.427692831489343 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4131.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4134, "annual_bias_pct": 1.3951226203753133, "hourly_rmse": 124.07347582122514, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 576.8959999999988, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 1078.1020639228411, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.4605578505628156, 1.2805912818836747, 1.047082140529988, 1.2133373135885048, 1.0905473278313884, 1.0815539540706065, 1.2495626610674906, 1.7297139989049137, 2.2992904041308524, 1.5025167202068141, 1.232407200072059, 1.2125955337766 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3951226203753133, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2992904041308524, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 26.97374098524164 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 124.07347582122514 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 72.19315958157785 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3820869874526294 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3752989537292923 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4134.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "makassar_reverse_dcac110", "site_id": "makassar", "site_name": "Makassar", "latitude": -5.092, "longitude": 119.495, "timezone": "Asia/Makassar", "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/makassar_reverse_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "f271c4d761ec8bed5461c5bf84e7464bd01b61bdb5ec28778cc64f5831391e4f", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "5797023f63b1dae91cf7d0dd3515185264c7e0fb6411402c94b1e592051a0af9", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1818.4399421999974, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1818.440346003095, "oracle_ac_kwh": 17314.121354099978, "engine_ac_kwh": 17553.41131120909, "ac_bias_pct": 1.3820508255387003 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4304, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.9014025990833496e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.997419580377027e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.9954400083152e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000018324812670833534, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997419580377027e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.9954400083152e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999450808895745e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.9014025990833496e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -4.183349808239194e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.7060208605885e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 6.038144719056459e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4304.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3925, "annual_bias_pct": 0.000022206017829443668, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006156503792118672, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0068316853835881375, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005420832430947568, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -2.0133806709314034e-6, -0.000017805625785741358, -0.000019813101967328242, -6.1003125935809055e-6, 0.000021945999606722257, 0.000018092914078239535, -0.000011443903493523862, -0.0000153911999752556, 0.00006426938250674055, 0.00008802468496890433, 0.00008062121690932447, 8.864125658721642e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000022206017829443668, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0068316853835881375, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005420832430947568, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00007760649874559105 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006156503792118672 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00007932699032373275 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000017191492615468357 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0001334217887851046 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3925.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4253, "annual_bias_pct": 0.00002263605348807877, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006914710969842387, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.009365983207828776, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.03631832090888242, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -2.8686763686497916e-6, -0.00001790272260312781, -0.000019134497447773217, -7.134906687454373e-6, 0.00002327573521456016, 0.000018117159210184474, -0.000011763431676377257, -0.000015950396335797496, 0.00006599219245416354, 0.00008970403188121644, 0.00008264931358512143, 8.58675241637171e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00002263605348807877, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00007755598544512677 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006914710969842387 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00009472718804444223 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 0.000022636052715841103 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00016523425350145856 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4253.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3925, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003363178319654973, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0001984101146952355, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0006861792921896979, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0001984101146952355, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003363178319654973 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 1.9985733025934784e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.978117800351183e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008377124740485482 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3925.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4129, "annual_bias_pct": 2.03259961970243, "hourly_rmse": 101.6773948844695, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 344.6085575803354, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 17.075412233020653, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.9970331716894558, 1.9493508003346678, 1.8750069073922035, 1.956979519006742, 2.0267677514041593, 2.0421006269932285, 1.9727706529322444, 2.1375278087467593, 2.201847163308995, 2.097518765456324, 2.115967226515063, 1.893631474950417 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.03259961970243, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 17.075412233020653, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 31.01215699143779 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 101.6773948844695 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 88.05449059473095 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0291255385735285 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.343051413530614 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4129.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4133, "annual_bias_pct": 1.3820508255389652, "hourly_rmse": 68.9653135787063, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 257.8499432771223, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 477.2919386405246, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.7049774185953461, 1.4002215979375867, 1.1691574576502117, 1.3742253975935077, 1.4440753965752178, 1.5718998640217714, 1.2495345096768558, 1.3413797502011886, 1.439461687962938, 1.3310501619272457, 1.3075397515888803, 1.3956474255324247 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3820508255389652, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.7049774185953461, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 20.16238977687381 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 68.9653135787063 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 57.2349848149022 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3662385020997634 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6462495277203153 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4133.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "medan_equator_dcac110", "site_id": "medan", "site_name": "Medan", "latitude": 3.652, "longitude": 98.685, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/medan_equator_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "917efc6288bf487d61d963ab20209fce2e0bc518ff019a5747f4a8330ec927cc", "hemisphere": "utara", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "1c2d4d6c657a58dff0f747ae30d36e04ff91895459a1967f95bddb0c7e1d99d3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1740.0032769999943, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1740.0032754099739, "oracle_ac_kwh": 16659.231385700055, "engine_ac_kwh": 16912.040037268132, "ac_bias_pct": 1.5175289046353173 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_solar_position_medan", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.839258545625466e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.995748206226835e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999547513762082e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 8.793050402711913e-6, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.995748206226835e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999547513762082e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997559557295972e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.839258545625466e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -7.435242530642529e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.5332441714076994e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.85492214713748e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_medan", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3956, "annual_bias_pct": -9.138031577095903e-8, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002857261324899563, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0000499994488336597, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00009106279128772, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.867687992750343e-8, 3.6268175247311276e-7, 1.7437070523306864e-7, -2.5837190060645326e-7, -5.199676204095656e-7, 1.1310086085846201e-7, -7.504299247545022e-7, -2.7286241690584954e-7, -5.450634539052956e-8, -1.8448237604301968e-7, -1.4487546827450777e-7, 3.9401309247705606e-7 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -9.138031577095903e-8, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0000499994488336597, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00009106279128772, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 4.834410986488366e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00002857261324899563 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -3.9385120485438696e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.97980836808886e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 6.514556471811683e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3956.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_effective_irradiance_medan", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": -3.346782735873919e-8, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002886308095839502, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.000049996816869679606, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.010940815147602041, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -3.647056100460029e-7, -1.077290917122657e-7, 3.8214465192101025e-7, -5.615931491207196e-7, -2.906339184144615e-7, -7.72310676019654e-8, -5.43914247031433e-7, 6.397944513313859e-8, 1.5463725288406523e-7, 3.603867727436845e-7, 1.296875636313538e-7, 5.855744179364796e-7 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -3.346782735873919e-8, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 5.069952858686779e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00002886308095839502 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -1.3110690236092563e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -3.346792747155593e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 7.3679377876073524e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_cell_temp_chain_medan", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3956, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002851514454272978, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.000049996756558812194, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00019868518006835222, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.000049996756558812194, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00002851514454272978 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -5.237960805055255e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.3133513196878612e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007149805832861555 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3956.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4073, "annual_bias_pct": 2.102359978031884, "hourly_rmse": 100.67282193033861, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 339.36572953112955, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.248174873033875, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.1130083786936313, 2.081224524550813, 2.1127018718324697, 2.1370750467374853, 2.1518295861986716, 2.1504095850355593, 2.1657524657565594, 2.1259722869744717, 2.1818820202350264, 2.017595250247563, 1.9871379209422377, 1.9803485033636314 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.102359978031884, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.248174873033875, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 30.37304209549967 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 100.67282193033861 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 88.28359936327304 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0858512633561865 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.378567869043939 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4073.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4166, "annual_bias_pct": 1.5175289046355547, "hourly_rmse": 68.07890195361254, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 252.6805083498839, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 20665.45312753891, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.4263438517247218, 1.4127228070824096, 1.5003312057827565, 1.5401134152344527, 1.606545693016316, 1.6315227850969845, 1.639855995116333, 1.5615101958982036, 1.6209018606155305, 1.3737848285510548, 1.4251887654074957, 1.4955247747132538 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5175289046355547, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.639855995116333, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 21.14731441418787 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 68.07890195361254 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 58.825977592239994 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.4710704052026917 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.7024597292177635 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4166.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "medan_equator_dcac130", "site_id": "medan", "site_name": "Medan", "latitude": 3.652, "longitude": 98.685, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 48, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.3221, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/medan_equator_dcac130.csv", "fixture_sha256": "23ac33047e179e6b9bfa247664375872105337424ac320edeefa717133472cb6", "hemisphere": "utara", "pnom_kwp": 13.221119999999999, "weather_sha256": "1c2d4d6c657a58dff0f747ae30d36e04ff91895459a1967f95bddb0c7e1d99d3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1740.0032769999943, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1740.0032754099739, "oracle_ac_kwh": 20024.775278100024, "engine_ac_kwh": 20288.75964580941, "ac_bias_pct": 1.318288789977533 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.839258545625466e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.995748206226835e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999547513762082e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 8.793050402711913e-6, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.995748206226835e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999547513762082e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.997559557295972e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.839258545625466e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -7.435242530642529e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.5332441714076994e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.85492214713748e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3956, "annual_bias_pct": -9.138031577095903e-8, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002857261324899563, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0000499994488336597, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00009106279128772, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.867687992750343e-8, 3.6268175247311276e-7, 1.7437070523306864e-7, -2.5837190060645326e-7, -5.199676204095656e-7, 1.1310086085846201e-7, -7.504299247545022e-7, -2.7286241690584954e-7, -5.450634539052956e-8, -1.8448237604301968e-7, -1.4487546827450777e-7, 3.9401309247705606e-7 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -9.138031577095903e-8, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0000499994488336597, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00009106279128772, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 4.834410986488366e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00002857261324899563 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -3.9385120485438696e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -8.97980836808886e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 6.514556471811683e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3956.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": -3.346782735873919e-8, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002886308095839502, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.000049996816869679606, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.010940815147602041, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -3.647056100460029e-7, -1.077290917122657e-7, 3.8214465192101025e-7, -5.615931491207196e-7, -2.906339184144615e-7, -7.72310676019654e-8, -5.43914247031433e-7, 6.397944513313859e-8, 1.5463725288406523e-7, 3.603867727436845e-7, 1.296875636313538e-7, 5.855744179364796e-7 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -3.346782735873919e-8, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 5.069952858686779e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00002886308095839502 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -1.3110690236092563e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -3.346792747155593e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 7.3679377876073524e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3956, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002851514454272978, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.000049996756558812194, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00019868518006835222, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.000049996756558812194, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00002851514454272978 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -5.237960805055255e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.3133513196878612e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007149805832861555 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3956.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4073, "annual_bias_pct": 2.1023599970669005, "hourly_rmse": 120.807387234331, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 407.2389354373554, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.24821038726227, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.113008414058271, 2.081224449095206, 2.112701903865561, 2.137075066428743, 2.151829685066922, 2.150409559673559, 2.165752408420781, 2.1259724164343434, 2.1818820289961747, 2.017595313724521, 1.9871380294377208, 1.9803483834757334 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.1023599970669005, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.24821038726227, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 36.44765085310813 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 120.807387234331 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 105.94032010997586 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.085851280924209 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.3785678875262146 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4073.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4201, "annual_bias_pct": 1.3182887899778224, "hourly_rmse": 86.30082089396731, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 576.8959999999988, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 26759.01306172766, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.2610508457999259, 1.3530016179912563, 1.37586933141322, 1.3476637768825248, 1.3294945898282209, 1.3381912963673792, 1.3472884868664465, 1.4187202052659822, 1.4834671623155462, 1.1605159844516644, 1.1463333716055668, 1.23299703203248 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.3182887899778224, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.4834671623155462, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 22.158203464732097 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 86.30082089396731 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 61.38769973650212 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.287853286798604 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.8105059534528563 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4201.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "medan_reverse_dcac110", "site_id": "medan", "site_name": "Medan", "latitude": 3.652, "longitude": 98.685, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/medan_reverse_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "364e6081a6b8306167f7781fb5e947b33bab6d327d38991fe0912420c07e4063", "hemisphere": "utara", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "1c2d4d6c657a58dff0f747ae30d36e04ff91895459a1967f95bddb0c7e1d99d3", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1721.496508700002, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1721.4965095236773, "oracle_ac_kwh": 16483.80353040001, "engine_ac_kwh": 16737.654608047054, "ac_bias_pct": 1.5400030531720539 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.839258545625466e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.995748206226835e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999547513762082e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 8.793050402711913e-6, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.995748206226835e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999547513762082e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998514242515739e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.839258545625466e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -7.435242530642529e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.5332441714076994e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.85492214713748e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3936, "annual_bias_pct": 4.784647647179418e-8, "hourly_rmse": 0.000028790348108942077, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.000049993811614967854, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.00009156589572474666, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -5.886361290034722e-7, 4.015356912689501e-8, 1.415739753937217e-7, 5.4606542574650604e-8, 1.6805072437164233e-7, 5.084530919973584e-7, -3.1801269260951633e-7, 2.5708271238304187e-7, 3.737169012861253e-7, 1.225891035563649e-7, 1.0050739609605941e-6, -1.3507313931118722e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 4.784647647179418e-8, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000049993811614967854, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00009156589572474666, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 6.787226984537639e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000028790348108942077 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 2.699362116000103e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 6.193245258906934e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 6.605474896128346e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3936.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": -2.1594746778965884e-9, "hourly_rmse": 0.000028837585799948268, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00004998146891921351, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.010940815147602041, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -6.383552827450996e-7, -1.3962555283051472e-7, -1.1276133007636933e-7, -8.923665804338346e-8, -5.720392798363356e-8, 1.7251187023956583e-8, -3.5026172610511105e-7, 4.0087335280393284e-7, 4.6194675350366517e-7, 3.000907289407867e-7, 3.5911154990487376e-7, -6.947153718713094e-8 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -2.1594746778965884e-9, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 4.406694333930886e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000028837585799948268 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -8.372328343061665e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -2.159939287924918e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 7.4396789024445e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3936, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00002917843066356831, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0000499838179379708, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000203340709967422, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0000499838179379708, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00002917843066356831 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 3.5809989879631305e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 8.993917384313781e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007328357133698338 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3936.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4094, "annual_bias_pct": 2.113162297010383, "hourly_rmse": 100.81480626012804, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 338.654951297347, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.02426141989052, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.027843151579269, 1.9869149839566427, 2.0858728675261626, 2.159768659538006, 2.196051905940792, 2.2040002659627818, 2.2246806923586573, 2.1715319729372915, 2.175808373223218, 1.9934565815349519, 2.00029166149396, 2.0389889438513493 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.113162297010383, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.02426141989052, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 30.41944064276173 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 100.81480626012804 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 87.4352970395445 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.0981483646142918 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.4192108684428426 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4094.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4188, "annual_bias_pct": 1.5400030531722035, "hourly_rmse": 69.2835564100565, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 251.82568924545194, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 98968.80441687134, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.4738320563237552, 1.3980078590890563, 1.492179041460564, 1.527201641734519, 1.5736598923526868, 1.565210831994497, 1.5850871239515218, 1.5457627625850905, 1.6116841703971756, 1.4057996524940033, 1.5848902449563675, 1.7630457634456715 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5400030531722035, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.7630457634456715, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 21.309694608973096 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 69.2835564100565 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 59.16612597742554 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5032194186037178 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.760270520758114 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4188.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "semarang_equator_dcac110", "site_id": "semarang", "site_name": "Semarang", "latitude": -6.966, "longitude": 110.419, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/semarang_equator_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "4211c118f24150bfc62c4362ff3df0dbd0ede1ee8ba1b3fad3b87163091e482d", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "4e2973ebab63ae299de8ef3ed15f7cf5807daf5af3b6218f4900a41fb2acfd61", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1958.3484921000006, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1958.348408268899, "oracle_ac_kwh": 18529.31030050002, "engine_ac_kwh": 18835.288532785376, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6513201372481745 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_solar_position_semarang", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4397, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.910059608818927e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.99914193596851e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.996243490040797e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000019075039333156154, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.99914193596851e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.996243490040797e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998566964786733e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.910059608818927e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -5.747583959726315e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.1721129568907369e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.934525875083472e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4397.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_semarang", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3905, "annual_bias_pct": -4.280703970418732e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0005073934584371075, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0051686618664490425, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005577949488086906, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -4.085600046639098e-6, -0.000012390307058865247, -0.000037488007227953077, -0.00004067828012633898, -0.00003330170452659205, -6.003354494642797e-6, -8.942167971972887e-7, 0.000021262058691449196, 0.000035194712779187414, 8.97615795669682e-6, -9.343006171561846e-7, 3.993170535346529e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -4.280703970418732e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0051686618664490425, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005577949488086906, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00003988896030268028 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0005073934584371075 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000018342699610295333 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -3.67736095591433e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00010172269802072595 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3905.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_effective_irradiance_semarang", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": -4.475223572902505e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0004980874327590166, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.005203997225279977, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.008235951017509848, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -4.285771726156322e-6, -0.000013673199650342431, -0.00003776907097626571, -0.00004126338516178186, -0.00003438269427948344, -5.496064396014603e-6, -7.964320675137838e-7, 0.00002166907160939308, 0.000035524048122645694, 8.91285520401759e-6, -1.5879704666450938e-6, 3.777427470949001e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -4.475223572902505e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000039821821525101063 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0004980874327590166 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000019691698724311606 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -4.475223498766932e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00011319757704659732 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_cell_temp_chain_semarang", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3905, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003270254952033015, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0001488781661365124, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000562193817569228, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0001488781661365124, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003270254952033015 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -9.650964195691605e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -2.3008229040367842e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007796399761835479 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3905.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4226, "annual_bias_pct": 2.25598954415386, "hourly_rmse": 122.01434075555795, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 382.71310465069473, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.640132649827144, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.025809357078625, 1.9071079612786337, 2.0889568475166453, 2.1857256715702054, 2.1778728601242827, 2.138511480941455, 2.148310978507637, 2.467140146436575, 2.6991910832623147, 2.604596503910483, 2.1172175889696216, 2.1854052518586653 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.25598954415386, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.640132649827144, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 37.167797598818204 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 122.01434075555795 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 101.85444580373606 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.244773251139591 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.689077793533693 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4226.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4329, "annual_bias_pct": 1.6513201372479784, "hourly_rmse": 83.48637245387324, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 295.8751484646673, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 404333.9032880636, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.5299801605089687, 1.6561896934313198, 1.4902180124519833, 1.5759925733740996, 1.4712031997934578, 1.4666915468651556, 1.4751384708262685, 1.750412319988945, 1.9877144943140963, 1.9270346756157328, 1.5308667946384624, 1.9288965537765417 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6513201372479784, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.9877144943140963, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 26.114219918488462 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 83.48637245387324 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 69.88862237854988 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6328068415400119 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.9504908736029125 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4329.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "semarang_equator_dcac130", "site_id": "semarang", "site_name": "Semarang", "latitude": -6.966, "longitude": 110.419, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 48, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.3221, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/semarang_equator_dcac130.csv", "fixture_sha256": "e803608f58106f5a596fdb8103f94e6b689b3f7bcf8e6aa427bee8e6dc693974", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 13.221119999999999, "weather_sha256": "4e2973ebab63ae299de8ef3ed15f7cf5807daf5af3b6218f4900a41fb2acfd61", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1958.3484921000006, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1958.348408268899, "oracle_ac_kwh": 22186.490392100037, "engine_ac_kwh": 22560.137656532173, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6841206420154737 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4397, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.910059608818927e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.99914193596851e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.996243490040797e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000019075039333156154, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.99914193596851e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.996243490040797e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.998566964786733e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.910059608818927e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -5.747583959726315e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.1721129568907369e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.934525875083472e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4397.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3905, "annual_bias_pct": -4.280703970418732e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0005073934584371075, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0051686618664490425, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005577949488086906, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -4.085600046639098e-6, -0.000012390307058865247, -0.000037488007227953077, -0.00004067828012633898, -0.00003330170452659205, -6.003354494642797e-6, -8.942167971972887e-7, 0.000021262058691449196, 0.000035194712779187414, 8.97615795669682e-6, -9.343006171561846e-7, 3.993170535346529e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -4.280703970418732e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0051686618664490425, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005577949488086906, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00003988896030268028 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0005073934584371075 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000018342699610295333 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -3.67736095591433e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00010172269802072595 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3905.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": -4.475223572902505e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0004980874327590166, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.005203997225279977, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.008235951017509848, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -4.285771726156322e-6, -0.000013673199650342431, -0.00003776907097626571, -0.00004126338516178186, -0.00003438269427948344, -5.496064396014603e-6, -7.964320675137838e-7, 0.00002166907160939308, 0.000035524048122645694, 8.91285520401759e-6, -1.5879704666450938e-6, 3.777427470949001e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -4.475223572902505e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000039821821525101063 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0004980874327590166 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000019691698724311606 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -4.475223498766932e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00011319757704659732 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3905, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003270254952033015, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0001488781661365124, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000562193817569228, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0001488781661365124, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003270254952033015 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -9.650964195691605e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -2.3008229040367842e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00007796399761835479 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3905.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4226, "annual_bias_pct": 2.2559895392686267, "hourly_rmse": 146.41720856089412, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 459.25578558083544, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.640081339884265, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.025809331634758, 1.9071080500608437, 2.0889568432422996, 2.18572575318794, 2.1778728303793824, 2.138511537390362, 2.1483109124436695, 2.4671401682527168, 2.699191044734232, 2.604596476148686, 2.117217542307368, 2.185405212426624 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2559895392686267, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.640081339884265, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 44.601356971577665 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 146.41720856089412 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 122.22533466632889 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2447732455408036 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.689077787035974 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4226.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4361, "annual_bias_pct": 1.68412064201527, "hourly_rmse": 136.44834372085637, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 576.8959999999988, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 79548.34098785026, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.2684543693077892, 1.3172086851329508, 1.391009393983422, 1.4193719199883108, 1.6367717174702174, 1.287890480468604, 1.4558546686521778, 2.300787522442364, 2.535432117804918, 2.171854827656245, 1.2811773444322512, 1.6216229175234582 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.68412064201527, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.535432117804918, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 33.468326360408085 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 136.44834372085637 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 85.40216692088153 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6786740190083378 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.682043065173278 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4361.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "semarang_reverse_dcac110", "site_id": "semarang", "site_name": "Semarang", "latitude": -6.966, "longitude": 110.419, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/semarang_reverse_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "2365ce145d550a373143f6f8b9d5fcc7392c7ec425133d4053068a45b591a4f2", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "4e2973ebab63ae299de8ef3ed15f7cf5807daf5af3b6218f4900a41fb2acfd61", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1844.8995695000028, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1844.8997082222447, "oracle_ac_kwh": 17478.16182580004, "engine_ac_kwh": 17759.49807778367, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6096443938878122 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4397, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.910059608818927e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 4.99914193596851e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.996243490040797e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000019075039333156154, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.99914193596851e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.996243490040797e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.995843312372017e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.910059608818927e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -5.747583959726315e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.1721129568907369e-8 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.934525875083472e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4397.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3904, "annual_bias_pct": 7.519229997639043e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0005806536992574447, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.005937465274286069, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.010343975890059854, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -3.8712894972002e-6, -0.000015120255601976124, -0.000032096682788105215, -0.000019961587524193915, -0.000029981088076481543, -0.000020713863174228095, 0.000031232542099910875, 0.00005128748475301732, 0.000023608940602476968, 0.00003705520710437163, 0.00003400441759153173, 7.194420499721554e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 7.519229997639043e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.005937465274286069, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.010343975890059854, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000047078762186865155 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0005806536992574447 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.000021533534273276613 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 4.579856981868211e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00012349625773656908 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3904.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": 7.593974480910972e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006298631879395159, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.005927169256608522, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.018057306970088637, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -3.4853388585296027e-6, -0.000016528581404578593, -0.00003335627687635187, -0.000019554181619294253, -0.000029648678511246508, -0.00002172132093658907, 0.000032620678119213596, 0.00005217746340860811, 0.00002462855934752325, 0.0000374448578120315, 0.00003364894866522771, 6.304636734002334e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 7.593974480910972e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.0000468999644006267 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006298631879395159 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00003139005754562791 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 7.593974559765926e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0001523783452258105 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3904, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.00003362406654349827, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00020623303532119053, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0006413257186430159, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00020623303532119053, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00003362406654349827 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 9.656415634493089e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.344727416822486e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008164444621458418 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3904.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4187, "annual_bias_pct": 2.1894341855126833, "hourly_rmse": 110.6025683343554, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 392.88366278151443, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.928511085436828, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.072478198856598, 1.8900767664467792, 2.0457032264220567, 2.1119214535424993, 2.013452194869039, 2.0175683222888665, 2.039617122784736, 2.2649369756370548, 2.5723643566460406, 2.5957945637831616, 2.1663569937222817, 2.2077489821785568 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.1894341855126833, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.928511085436828, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 33.844478791861 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 110.6025683343554 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 93.99474203459953 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.1755915237073133 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.5599943673435255 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4187.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4276, "annual_bias_pct": 1.6096443938877345, "hourly_rmse": 76.27858722422823, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 306.0810442702532, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 7425.798561995614, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.4745710775048257, 1.5687913930562742, 1.4514293245377337, 1.5879724672668696, 1.3931440850347967, 1.4891724541110047, 1.52763980294643, 1.6171578039057084, 1.8733472540020926, 1.8959129087101672, 1.5077357046604074, 1.8207460952134897 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6096443938877345, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.8959129087101672, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 23.946100090307564 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 76.27858722422823 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 64.35337791890504 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5743935015811772 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.8661415440686366 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4276.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "surabaya_equator_dcac110", "site_id": "surabaya", "site_name": "Surabaya", "latitude": -7.1632, "longitude": 112.6375, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/surabaya_equator_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "bf2c200151bf4a7d596d88d41e71943b992eb03506fcab8c8a7438e2c7154d63", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "825d1aea192d07ea25949863bec53e51dcf85b02f620c21b9288c6ff1d8deb8d", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 2054.9974431999935, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 2054.99735175928, "oracle_ac_kwh": 19339.66179590003, "engine_ac_kwh": 19648.863733684833, "ac_bias_pct": 1.5987970267936888 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_solar_position_surabaya", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.881475087711785e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 5.000003255872798e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999135825300982e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000011377063690372827, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 5.000003255872798e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999135825300982e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.996470019946742e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.881475087711785e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -1.7196212985280748e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -3.518100789645315e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.895088523327352e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_poa_surabaya", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3994, "annual_bias_pct": -4.44967529284864e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0007257343156106706, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00864302565898356, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005237189185793177, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 7.946370803487556e-6, 8.213559610658927e-7, -0.000026365440902164705, -0.00004621157786640708, -0.00006612730825703107, -0.00001776631378446506, 0.000010839241216812686, 0.00003645465769699744, 0.00004390654311355686, 8.00666818864677e-6, -0.00001658251776470511, -3.611401415362606e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -4.44967529284864e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00864302565898356, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005237189185793177, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005545078579733446 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0007257343156106706 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000023047239703258454 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -4.489754436370656e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00014137783548451386 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3994.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_effective_irradiance_surabaya", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": -4.775800163368656e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006945095873910926, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.008648437400253783, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.006788140663328063, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 7.795159783448682e-6, 4.3332510219637093e-7, -0.00002733047538097231, -0.00004664392246583522, -0.00006798055510562791, -0.000018592969146345967, 0.000010813751045694108, 0.00003692829003417978, 0.00004502468862825319, 8.085332752257244e-6, -0.000018050257250580987, -3.0747176975449316e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -4.775800163368656e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000055762495237439374 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006945095873910926 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000021984449187892355 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -4.775800122231752e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00015087205251338337 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "PASS", "gate": { "gated": true, "ci_test": "oracle_cell_temp_chain_surabaya", "reason": null, "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3994, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.0000352833389043251, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0002520821745903845, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0007200187789102826, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0002520821745903845, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0000352833389043251 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -6.576198560228183e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.5223842746623e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008168062416847289 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3994.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4104, "annual_bias_pct": 2.2815921387229166, "hourly_rmse": 130.0557389313978, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 379.96588237373, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.301569133554292, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.023635477582846003, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.0115544983841374, 2.3254649682131343, 2.2302391474625893, 2.326152812245434, 2.350732870797002, 2.229938809976177, 2.2820572882805013, 2.3808203256046987, 2.6745352314719266, 2.409155834617008, 2.618284999615031, 1.3311926490675208 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2815921387229166, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.301569133554292, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 38.936479178361864 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 130.0557389313978 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 110.43613625369012 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2665984701851083 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.6692724763888154 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.023635477582846003 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4104.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4181, "annual_bias_pct": 1.5987970267937728, "hourly_rmse": 87.24527107927706, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 293.303555078779, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 8953.790188552144, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.4494335891662031, 1.7410414152877938, 1.5826362152088462, 1.7336331307869435, 1.583351960580823, 1.466104684942027, 1.5570643094885492, 1.673859523900946, 1.9360840828591974, 1.740226784648138, 1.8625681763737219, 0.7302675013816865 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5987970267937728, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.9360840828591974, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 26.507550952224065 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 87.24527107927706 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 71.64470727582402 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5488715587762942 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.8861368013156699 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4181.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "surabaya_equator_dcac130", "site_id": "surabaya", "site_name": "Surabaya", "latitude": -7.1632, "longitude": 112.6375, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 48, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.3221, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/surabaya_equator_dcac130.csv", "fixture_sha256": "74616558df72e9029dd5db497e32adf0d44aa99231fdb01b972b75941080a1ca", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 13.221119999999999, "weather_sha256": "825d1aea192d07ea25949863bec53e51dcf85b02f620c21b9288c6ff1d8deb8d", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 2054.9974431999935, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 2054.99735175928, "oracle_ac_kwh": 23153.921259499963, "engine_ac_kwh": 23530.996170378294, "ac_bias_pct": 1.6285574553537827 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.881475087711785e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 5.000003255872798e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999135825300982e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000011377063690372827, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 5.000003255872798e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999135825300982e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.996470019946742e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.881475087711785e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -1.7196212985280748e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -3.518100789645315e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.895088523327352e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3994, "annual_bias_pct": -4.44967529284864e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0007257343156106706, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00864302565898356, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.005237189185793177, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 7.946370803487556e-6, 8.213559610658927e-7, -0.000026365440902164705, -0.00004621157786640708, -0.00006612730825703107, -0.00001776631378446506, 0.000010839241216812686, 0.00003645465769699744, 0.00004390654311355686, 8.00666818864677e-6, -0.00001658251776470511, -3.611401415362606e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -4.44967529284864e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00864302565898356, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.005237189185793177, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00005545078579733446 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0007257343156106706 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000023047239703258454 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -4.489754436370656e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00014137783548451386 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3994.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": -4.775800163368656e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006945095873910926, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.008648437400253783, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.006788140663328063, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 7.795159783448682e-6, 4.3332510219637093e-7, -0.00002733047538097231, -0.00004664392246583522, -0.00006798055510562791, -0.000018592969146345967, 0.000010813751045694108, 0.00003692829003417978, 0.00004502468862825319, 8.085332752257244e-6, -0.000018050257250580987, -3.0747176975449316e-6 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": -4.775800163368656e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.000055762495237439374 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006945095873910926 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": -0.000021984449187892355 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -4.775800122231752e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00015087205251338337 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3994, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.0000352833389043251, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.0002520821745903845, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0007200187789102826, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0002520821745903845, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0000352833389043251 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": -6.576198560228183e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -1.5223842746623e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008168062416847289 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3994.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4104, "annual_bias_pct": 2.2815921341227887, "hourly_rmse": 156.06688600309437, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 455.9591188484719, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.301551896882568, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.023635477582846003, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.0115544983839, 2.3254650368226817, 2.2302391495126463, 2.326152804035956, 2.350732876665003, 2.229938771164903, 2.282057247609819, 2.3808203818633222, 2.674535191466737, 2.4091558582267956, 2.618284955080681, 1.3311926323538714 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2815921341227887, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.301551896882568, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 46.72377488095729 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 156.06688600309437 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 132.52336317304355 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.2665984643888377 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.66927246401573 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.023635477582846003 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4104.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4220, "annual_bias_pct": 1.6285574553542947, "hourly_rmse": 138.22468949502294, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 576.8959999999988, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 7146.356125265616, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.1655341963586283, 1.5498844717653502, 1.4955746370621257, 1.656538893160138, 1.4826072203631708, 1.3567090755306301, 1.7206126818660268, 1.6871666702587627, 2.8195198777005195, 1.732153071059051, 1.8070495287410695, 0.6990269204958279 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.6285574553542947, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 2.8195198777005195, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 33.664696436922185 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 138.22468949502294 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 87.461592686838 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.594062262723732 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.5192630791627475 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4220.0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "surabaya_reverse_dcac110", "site_id": "surabaya", "site_name": "Surabaya", "latitude": -7.1632, "longitude": 112.6375, "timezone": "Asia/Jakarta", "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "tilt_deg": 10.0, "module_wp": 275.44, "module_count": 40, "inverter_ac_kw": 10.0, "dc_ac_ratio": 1.1018, "reference_transposition": "perez", "reference_temperature_model": "sapm", "fixture": "tools/oracle/fixtures/stages/surabaya_reverse_dcac110.csv", "fixture_sha256": "95a9815a9f966f573799738979c08e15d0f2a5e7b82123c56adc1e56de3447ba", "hemisphere": "selatan", "pnom_kwp": 11.0176, "weather_sha256": "825d1aea192d07ea25949863bec53e51dcf85b02f620c21b9288c6ff1d8deb8d", "models": { "transposition_reference": "perez", "transposition_engine": "transposisi bidang modul: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah (default Perez 1990; Hay-Davies 1980 / Liu-Jordan 1963)", "temperature_reference": "sapm", "temperature_engine": "model suhu sel di output.thermal (bawaan Sandia/SAPM per racking) dari shaded_irradiance, temp_air, wind_speed", "iam_engine": "irradiance efektif setelah IAM: langsung + difus langit + pantulan tanah", "dc_engine": "output at cell temperature: Pmp(G_eff, T_cell) model single-diode; tanpa karakterisasi, PVWatts linear (warning)", "ac_engine": "actual_dc x efisiensi inverter datar; kurva efisiensi menyusul" }, "annual": { "oracle_poa_kwh_m2": 1949.971626999999, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1949.9717642115927, "oracle_ac_kwh": 18400.069566500017, "engine_ac_kwh": 18685.682554659037, "ac_bias_pct": 1.552238632178979 }, "stages": [ { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "solar_position", "engine_column": "solar_zenith", "oracle_column": "zenith", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 2.881475087711785e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 5.000003255872798e-7, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": 4.999135825300982e-7, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.000011377063690372827, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "zenith_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 5.000003255872798e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.zenith_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "azimuth_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999135825300982e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.azimuth_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "aoi_max_abs_diff", "unit": "deg", "value": 4.999718044018664e-7, "tolerance": 0.01, "tolerance_key": "solar_position.aoi_max_abs_diff_deg", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "deg", "value": 2.881475087711785e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "deg", "value": -1.7196212985280748e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": -3.518100789645315e-9 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 5.895088523327352e-7 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "poa", "engine_column": "poa_irradiance", "oracle_column": "poa_global", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3948, "annual_bias_pct": 7.036594373959735e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006758978598803829, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.006093068767739851, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.007749672418879817, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.000016163681811394938, -0.00003968964736279265, -0.0000242174645709758, -3.7563012301833407e-6, 0.000029317106750750523, -2.770937440079558e-6, 2.3181227593743487e-6, 5.285861708108964e-6, 9.531133203012769e-6, 0.00003752385726909, 0.00005239939960643996, 0.0000160065727088962 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 7.036594373959735e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.006093068767739851, "tolerance": 2.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_abs_diff_w_m2", "within_tolerance": true }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 0.007749672418879817, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "poa.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00004499720647194446 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006758978598803829 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00003469117379667997 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 7.048190526959402e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00013732187100734425 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3948.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "effective_irradiance", "engine_column": "effective_irradiance", "oracle_column": "effective_irradiance", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4380, "annual_bias_pct": 7.2223960872799e-6, "hourly_rmse": 0.0006439082479008667, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.006079945338100856, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.009711641248500377, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ -0.00001672577991046725, -0.000040090375654661624, -0.000024740955068911263, -3.2886322687803968e-6, 0.000029484466651034957, -2.9349645970805334e-6, 3.1950483966049794e-6, 4.975180608329214e-6, 8.89997730274782e-6, 0.000038162224803874766, 0.000053839575040159265, 0.000017005712784040247 ], "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 7.2223960872799e-6, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "effective_irradiance.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh/m2", "value": 0.00004523572792515836 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.0006439082479008667 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W/m2", "value": 0.00003151290916438702 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 7.222395849359619e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.0001475763545900509 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4380.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "tidak ada test CI yang membandingkan kasus ini; tahap ini dijaga pada kasus equator_dcac110", "pending_issue": null }, "stage": "cell_temperature", "engine_column": "avg_cell_temp", "oracle_column": "cell_temperature", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 3948, "annual_bias_pct": null, "hourly_rmse": 0.0000348833793669045, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 0.00021732267901342084, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 0.0006759494244883942, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": null, "within_tolerance": true, "metrics": [ { "name": "hourly_max_abs_diff", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.00021732267901342084, "tolerance": 0.2, "tolerance_key": "cell_temperature.hourly_max_abs_diff_deg_c", "within_tolerance": true } ], "informational": [ { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "degC", "value": 0.0000348833793669045 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "degC", "value": 1.0674875965935048e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.5065018248844374e-6 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 0.00008190751285569949 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 3948.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: harness oracle ujung-ke ujung belum menautkan karakterisasi modul (oracle_dc_ terisolasi aktif)", "pending_issue": "#14" }, "stage": "dc", "engine_column": "module_mpp_power", "oracle_column": "p_mp", "engine_status": "modeled", "pending_issue": null, "n_points": 4112, "annual_bias_pct": 2.214703362569447, "hourly_rmse": 119.3945083590936, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 379.8003982134742, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 18.432507869920382, "hourly_pass_fraction": 0.024075875486381324, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 2.0431263170736704, 2.333879411642777, 2.1760517927981113, 2.2764105176209624, 2.242997645306641, 2.108429330467207, 2.0984428402230377, 2.2389368166226133, 2.526077981467859, 2.4140017716766082, 2.7239714834518716, 1.2964845348477696 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 2.214703362569447, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "hourly_max_rel_diff", "unit": "%", "value": 18.432507869920382, "tolerance": 0.5, "tolerance_key": "dc_power.hourly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 36.05957421076018 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 119.3945083590936 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 101.89154623993254 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 2.201274052786233 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 2.5794096075169715 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 0.024075875486381324 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4112.0 } ] }, { "verdict": "NOT_GATED", "gate": { "gated": false, "ci_test": null, "reason": "test oracle tahap ini masih #[ignore]: menunggu ENG-12", "pending_issue": "#15" }, "stage": "ac", "engine_column": "ac_power", "oracle_column": "p_ac", "engine_status": "approximated", "pending_issue": "#15", "n_points": 4150, "annual_bias_pct": 1.5522386321786095, "hourly_rmse": 81.09705820241147, "hourly_max_abs_diff": 293.0693982849334, "hourly_max_abs_diff_azimuth": null, "hourly_max_rel_diff_pct": 117030.99747389444, "hourly_pass_fraction": 1.0, "monthly_bias_pct": [ 1.3817622311089848, 1.6939411896762295, 1.535169320039651, 1.7657555628424093, 1.6040126058347322, 1.507459832854578, 1.4732916159837015, 1.600845591247089, 1.7833776268955166, 1.7296813956765105, 1.948456224242119, 0.5919953431964757 ], "within_tolerance": false, "metrics": [ { "name": "annual_bias", "unit": "%", "value": 1.5522386321786095, "tolerance": 1.0, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false }, { "name": "monthly_bias_max_abs", "unit": "%", "value": 1.948456224242119, "tolerance": 1.5, "tolerance_key": "ac_power.monthly_max_rel_diff_pct", "within_tolerance": false } ], "informational": [ { "name": "monthly_rmse", "unit": "kWh", "value": 24.64380931119443 }, { "name": "hourly_rmse", "unit": "W", "value": 81.09705820241147 }, { "name": "hourly_mbe", "unit": "W", "value": 66.34842649753418 }, { "name": "hourly_nmbe", "unit": "%", "value": 1.4964398312171272 }, { "name": "hourly_nrmse", "unit": "%", "value": 1.8290843429893906 }, { "name": "hourly_pass_fraction", "unit": "fraction", "value": 1.0 }, { "name": "hours_compared", "unit": "hours", "value": 4150.0 } ] } ] } ], "hemisphere_checks": [ { "site_id": "medan", "description": "POA tahunan engine untuk azimuth 180 dan 0 terhadap pvlib Perez; tanda POA(180) - POA(0) harus sama dengan oracle", "tolerance_key": "poa.annual_max_rel_diff_pct", "tolerance": 0.5, "south_facing": { "azimuth_deg": 180.0, "oracle_isotropic_poa_kwh_m2": 1740.0032769999943, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1740.0032754099739, "bias_pct": -9.138031577095903e-8, "within_tolerance": true }, "north_facing": { "azimuth_deg": 0.0, "oracle_isotropic_poa_kwh_m2": 1721.496508700002, "engine_poa_kwh_m2": 1721.4965095236773, "bias_pct": 4.784647647179418e-8, "within_tolerance": true }, "sign_matches_oracle": true, "south_beats_north_in_engine": true, "verdict": "PASS", "ci_test": "oracle_medan_north_of_equator" } ], "spectral_effects": [ { "site_id": "bali", "technology": "MonoSi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.2770548078792485, "annual_factor": 0.9993340975573268, "effect_pct": -0.06659024426731719 }, { "site_id": "bali", "technology": "PolySi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.2770548078792485, "annual_factor": 1.0032339950003188, "effect_pct": 0.32339950003188456 }, { "site_id": "balikpapan", "technology": "MonoSi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.5834427586791255, "annual_factor": 0.9987190117768061, "effect_pct": -0.12809882231938907 }, { "site_id": "balikpapan", "technology": "PolySi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.5834427586791255, "annual_factor": 1.0028248527174615, "effect_pct": 0.2824852717461468 }, { "site_id": "cikarang", "technology": "MonoSi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.308143890714104, "annual_factor": 1.0000751517398943, "effect_pct": 0.00751517398942525 }, { "site_id": "cikarang", "technology": "PolySi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.308143890714104, "annual_factor": 1.0043925618061649, "effect_pct": 0.4392561806164874 }, { "site_id": "makassar", "technology": "MonoSi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.377846033731531, "annual_factor": 1.0004461657880095, "effect_pct": 0.044616578800948936 }, { "site_id": "makassar", "technology": "PolySi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.377846033731531, "annual_factor": 1.004820315704198, "effect_pct": 0.48203157041979416 }, { "site_id": "medan", "technology": "MonoSi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.5843690584358665, "annual_factor": 0.999852092027365, "effect_pct": -0.014790797263497524 }, { "site_id": "medan", "technology": "PolySi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.5843690584358665, "annual_factor": 1.0043539871599179, "effect_pct": 0.43539871599178603 }, { "site_id": "semarang", "technology": "MonoSi", "mean_pw_cm": 3.9922441602986876, "annual_factor": 0.9995857848450438, "effect_pct": -0.04142151549562101 }, { "site_id": "semarang", "technology": "PolySi", "mean_pw_cm": 3.9922441602986876, "annual_factor": 1.003527368856232, "effect_pct": 0.35273688562320604 }, { "site_id": "surabaya", "technology": "MonoSi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.230012661258472, "annual_factor": 0.9992344069780892, "effect_pct": -0.07655930219108154 }, { "site_id": "surabaya", "technology": "PolySi", "mean_pw_cm": 4.230012661258472, "annual_factor": 1.0029094117601896, "effect_pct": 0.2909411760189551 } ], "summary": { "cases": 24, "sites": 7, "stage_results": { "FAIL": 0, "NOT_GATED": 113, "PASS": 31 }, "hemisphere_checks": { "FAIL": 0, "PASS": 1 } }, "telemetry": { "title": "Validasi terhadap data terukur", "status": "belum_ada_data", "note": "Belum ada data telemetri berizin", "source_issue": "#70", "cases": [] } }